Main Article Content
Abstract
This study examines whether selected technical trading strategies outperform the Buy-and-Hold strategy using 20 years of daily data from the Indonesia Stock Exchange within the frameworks of the Efficient Market Hypothesis and technical analysis. Five technical strategies—Simple Moving Average (SMA), Exponential Moving Average (EMA), Relative Strength Index (RSI), Moving Average Convergence Divergence (MACD), and and Bollinger Bands—were evaluated against Buy-and-Hold. Daily adjusted closing prices were used to calculate mean daily returns, cumulative returns, final wealth, annualized volatility, and Sharpe ratios. Paired t-tests and Wilcoxon signed-rank tests were employed for parametric and non-parametric comparisons. EMA achieved the highest cumulative return (1404.57%), final wealth (15.05), and Sharpe ratio (0.8435). However, paired t-tests showed that neither EMA nor SMA generated significantly higher mean daily returns than Buy-and-Hold. MACD also showed no significant superiority, while RSI and Bollinger Bands performed significantly worse than the benchmark. Technical trading strategies did not consistently outperform Buy-and-Hold, although EMA demonstrated comparatively strong cumulative and risk-adjusted performance. Investors should not rely solely on technical trading strategies for superior returns. EMA may be considered alongside appropriate risk-management practices, while future studies should test these strategies across different markets and periods.
[Penelitian ini menguji apakah strategi perdagangan teknikal tertentu mengungguli strategi beli dan tahan (Buy-and-Hold) dengan menggunakan data harian selama 20 tahun dari Bursa Efek Indonesia, dalam kerangka Hipotesis Pasar Efisien dan analisis teknikal. Lima strategi teknikal, yaitu Simple Moving Average (SMA), Exponential Moving Average (EMA), Relative Strength Index (RSI), Moving Average Convergence Divergence (MACD), dan Bollinger Bands, dibandingkan dengan Buy-and-Hold. Harga penutupan yang telah disesuaikan digunakan untuk menghitung rata-rata imbal hasil harian, imbal hasil kumulatif, kekayaan akhir, volatilitas tahunan, dan rasio Sharpe. Uji t berpasangan dan uji peringkat bertanda Wilcoxon digunakan untuk perbandingan parametrik dan nonparametrik. EMA menghasilkan imbal hasil kumulatif tertinggi (1404,57%), kekayaan akhir (15,05), dan rasio Sharpe (0,8435). Namun, uji t berpasangan menunjukkan bahwa EMA maupun SMA tidak menghasilkan rata-rata imbal hasil harian yang secara signifikan lebih tinggi daripada Buy-and-Hold. MACD juga tidak menunjukkan keunggulan signifikan, sedangkan RSI dan Bollinger Bands berkinerja secara signifikan lebih buruk daripada strategi acuan. Strategi perdagangan teknikal tidak secara konsisten mengungguli Buy-and-Hold, meskipun EMA menunjukkan kinerja kumulatif dan kinerja setelah penyesuaian risiko yang relatif kuat. Investor sebaiknya tidak hanya mengandalkan strategi perdagangan teknikal untuk memperoleh imbal hasil yang lebih tinggi. EMA dapat dipertimbangkan bersama praktik pengelolaan risiko yang tepat, sedangkan penelitian selanjutnya perlu menguji strategi tersebut pada pasar dan periode yang berbeda.]
Keywords
Article Details
Copyright (c) 2026 Irfan Ullah Stanikzai, Abdullah khalili (Author)

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
-
-
Authors retain copyright and grant the journal right of first publication with the work simultaneously licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License (CC BY-SA 4.0): https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/
Others may share and adapt the work, including for commercial purposes, provided that appropriate credit is given to the author(s) and source, a link to the license is provided, and changes are indicated. Adaptations must be distributed under the same license. No additional legal terms or technological measures may restrict the uses permitted by the license.
Authors are able to enter into separate, additional contractual arrangements for the non-exclusive distribution of the journal's published version of the work (e.g., post it to an institutional repository or publish it in a book), with an acknowledgement of its initial publication in this journal.
Authors are permitted and encouraged to post their work online (e.g., in institutional repositories or on their website) prior to and during the submission process, as it can lead to productive exchanges, as well as earlier and greater citation of published work.
-
How to Cite
References
- Abbasi, E., Samavi, M. E., & Koosha, E. (2020). Performance evaluation of the technical analysis indicators in comparison with the buy and hold strategy in Tehran Stock Exchange indices. Advances in Mathematical Finance and Applications, 5(3), 285–301. https://doi.org/10.22034/AMFA.2020.1893194.1376
- Ansary, O. E., & Atuea, M. (2017). Testing the effect of technical analysis strategies on achieving abnormal return: Evidence from Egyptian stock market. Accounting and Finance Research, 6(2), 26–42.
- de Souza, M. J. S., Ramos, D. G. F., Pena, M. G., Sobreiro, V. A., & Kimura, H. (2018). Examination of the profitability of technical analysis based on moving average strategies in BRICS. Financial Innovation, 4(1), Article 3.
- Indra, Supian, S., Sukono, Riaman, Saputra, M. P. A., Azahra, A. S., & Pirdaus, D. I. (2025). Stock return prediction on the LQ45 market index in the Indonesia Stock Exchange using a machine learning algorithm based on technical indicators. Journal of Risk and Financial Management, 18(12), Article 714.
- Jakpar, S., Tinggi, M., Tak, A. H., & Chong, W. Y. (2018). Fundamental analysis vs. technical analysis: The comparison of two analyses in the Malaysia stock market. UNIMAS Review of Accounting and Finance, 2(1).
- Khand, S., Anand, V., & Qureshi, M. N. (2020). The predictability and profitability of simple moving averages and trading range breakout rules in the Pakistan stock market. Review of Pacific Basin Financial Markets and Policies, 23(1), Article 2050001.
- Kung, J. J., & Wong, W.-K. (2009). Profitability of technical analysis in the Singapore stock market: Before and after the Asian financial crisis. Journal of Economic Integration, 24(1), 135–150. https://doi.org/10.11130/jei.2009.24.1.135
- Ling, F. C. H., Yat, D. N. C., & Muhamad, R. B. (2014). An empirical re-investigation on the buy-and-hold strategy in four Asian markets: A 20 years’ study. World Applied Sciences Journal, 30(30), 226–237.
- Lohpetch, D., & Corne, D. (2010). Outperforming buy-and-hold with evolved technical trading rules: Daily, weekly and monthly trading. In European conference on the applications of evolutionary computation (pp. 171–181). Springer.
- M’ng, J. C. P. (2018). Dynamically adjustable moving average (AMA’) technical analysis indicator to forecast Asian Tigers’ futures markets. Physica A: Statistical Mechanics and Its Applications, 509, 336–345.
- Metghalchi, M., Hayes, L. A., & Niroomand, F. (2019). A technical approach to equity investing in emerging markets. Review of Financial Economics, 37(3), 389–403.
- Rink, K. (2023). The predictive ability of technical trading rules: An empirical analysis of developed and emerging equity markets. Financial Markets and Portfolio Management, 37(4), 403–456. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11408-023-00433-2
- Saivasan, R., & Lokhande, M. (2025). Empirical analysis of moving averages strategy and buy-and-hold strategy in emerging markets: A comparative study. International Journal of Financial Markets and Derivatives, 10(2), 135–154.
- Sulistiawan, D., Rudiawarni, F. A., & Feliana, Y. K. (2020). Examining trading strategies using trend following indicators for Indonesian stock market. International Journal of Trade and Global Markets, 13(1), 52–60.
- Tadas, H., Nagarkar, J., Malik, S., Mishra, D. K., & Dipen, P. (2023). The effectiveness of technical trading strategies: Evidence from Indian equity markets. Investment Management & Financial Innovations, 20(2), 26.
- Tharavanij, P., Siraprapasiri, V., & Rajchamaha, K. (2015). Performance of technical trading rules: Evidence from Southeast Asian stock markets. SpringerPlus, 4(1), Article 552.
- Tzang, S. W., Tsai, Y. S., Chang, C. P., & Yang, Y. P. (2017). Moving average timing strategy from a volatility perspective: Evidence of the Taiwan stock market. In International conference on innovative mobile and internet services in ubiquitous computing (pp. 699–707). Springer.
- Wijaya, A. Y., Fatichah, C., Saikhu, A., & Arifin, S. (2026). Stock buy and sell prediction based on technical and news sentiment analysis using recurrent neural network architecture and ensemble methods. International Journal of Intelligent Engineering & Systems, 19(5), 715.
References
Abbasi, E., Samavi, M. E., & Koosha, E. (2020). Performance evaluation of the technical analysis indicators in comparison with the buy and hold strategy in Tehran Stock Exchange indices. Advances in Mathematical Finance and Applications, 5(3), 285–301. https://doi.org/10.22034/AMFA.2020.1893194.1376
Ansary, O. E., & Atuea, M. (2017). Testing the effect of technical analysis strategies on achieving abnormal return: Evidence from Egyptian stock market. Accounting and Finance Research, 6(2), 26–42.
de Souza, M. J. S., Ramos, D. G. F., Pena, M. G., Sobreiro, V. A., & Kimura, H. (2018). Examination of the profitability of technical analysis based on moving average strategies in BRICS. Financial Innovation, 4(1), Article 3.
Indra, Supian, S., Sukono, Riaman, Saputra, M. P. A., Azahra, A. S., & Pirdaus, D. I. (2025). Stock return prediction on the LQ45 market index in the Indonesia Stock Exchange using a machine learning algorithm based on technical indicators. Journal of Risk and Financial Management, 18(12), Article 714.
Jakpar, S., Tinggi, M., Tak, A. H., & Chong, W. Y. (2018). Fundamental analysis vs. technical analysis: The comparison of two analyses in the Malaysia stock market. UNIMAS Review of Accounting and Finance, 2(1).
Khand, S., Anand, V., & Qureshi, M. N. (2020). The predictability and profitability of simple moving averages and trading range breakout rules in the Pakistan stock market. Review of Pacific Basin Financial Markets and Policies, 23(1), Article 2050001.
Kung, J. J., & Wong, W.-K. (2009). Profitability of technical analysis in the Singapore stock market: Before and after the Asian financial crisis. Journal of Economic Integration, 24(1), 135–150. https://doi.org/10.11130/jei.2009.24.1.135
Ling, F. C. H., Yat, D. N. C., & Muhamad, R. B. (2014). An empirical re-investigation on the buy-and-hold strategy in four Asian markets: A 20 years’ study. World Applied Sciences Journal, 30(30), 226–237.
Lohpetch, D., & Corne, D. (2010). Outperforming buy-and-hold with evolved technical trading rules: Daily, weekly and monthly trading. In European conference on the applications of evolutionary computation (pp. 171–181). Springer.
M’ng, J. C. P. (2018). Dynamically adjustable moving average (AMA’) technical analysis indicator to forecast Asian Tigers’ futures markets. Physica A: Statistical Mechanics and Its Applications, 509, 336–345.
Metghalchi, M., Hayes, L. A., & Niroomand, F. (2019). A technical approach to equity investing in emerging markets. Review of Financial Economics, 37(3), 389–403.
Rink, K. (2023). The predictive ability of technical trading rules: An empirical analysis of developed and emerging equity markets. Financial Markets and Portfolio Management, 37(4), 403–456. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11408-023-00433-2
Saivasan, R., & Lokhande, M. (2025). Empirical analysis of moving averages strategy and buy-and-hold strategy in emerging markets: A comparative study. International Journal of Financial Markets and Derivatives, 10(2), 135–154.
Sulistiawan, D., Rudiawarni, F. A., & Feliana, Y. K. (2020). Examining trading strategies using trend following indicators for Indonesian stock market. International Journal of Trade and Global Markets, 13(1), 52–60.
Tadas, H., Nagarkar, J., Malik, S., Mishra, D. K., & Dipen, P. (2023). The effectiveness of technical trading strategies: Evidence from Indian equity markets. Investment Management & Financial Innovations, 20(2), 26.
Tharavanij, P., Siraprapasiri, V., & Rajchamaha, K. (2015). Performance of technical trading rules: Evidence from Southeast Asian stock markets. SpringerPlus, 4(1), Article 552.
Tzang, S. W., Tsai, Y. S., Chang, C. P., & Yang, Y. P. (2017). Moving average timing strategy from a volatility perspective: Evidence of the Taiwan stock market. In International conference on innovative mobile and internet services in ubiquitous computing (pp. 699–707). Springer.
Wijaya, A. Y., Fatichah, C., Saikhu, A., & Arifin, S. (2026). Stock buy and sell prediction based on technical and news sentiment analysis using recurrent neural network architecture and ensemble methods. International Journal of Intelligent Engineering & Systems, 19(5), 715.