Main Article Content

Abstract

Market value does not always reflect the value that the law should recognize. The same asset may have different legally relevant values depending on the legal purpose, asset characteristics, market and information conditions, valuation method, valuation date, and legal consequences of valuation. This article argues that legal valuation should move beyond a uniform reliance on market value. Using doctrinal and comparative legal analysis, it develops a context-specific framework for determining legally relevant value based on these six dimensions. The article conceptualizes valuation not merely as a technical exercise but as a form of legal governance through which economic value is translated into legally operative outcomes. Applying the framework to secured transactions, compensation, taxation, insolvency, and enforcement, the article demonstrates why different legal contexts may require different valuation approaches. It concludes that context-sensitive valuation can improve consistency, transparency, and fairness in legal valuation while aligning valuation outcomes more closely with the purposes of law.


[Nilai pasar tidak selalu mencerminkan nilai yang seharusnya diakui oleh hukum. Aset yang sama dapat memiliki nilai relevan secara hukum yang berbeda, bergantung pada tujuan hukum, karakteristik aset, kondisi pasar dan informasi, metode penilaian, tanggal penilaian, serta konsekuensi hukum dari penilaian tersebut. Artikel ini berargumen bahwa penilaian aset dalam konteks hukum perlu melampaui pendekatan seragam yang bertumpu pada nilai pasar. Melalui analisis hukum doktrinal dan komparatif, artikel ini mengembangkan kerangka penentuan nilai yang relevan secara hukum berdasarkan enam dimensi tersebut. Artikel ini memandang penilaian aset bukan semata-mata sebagai kegiatan teknis, melainkan juga sebagai bentuk tata kelola hukum yang menerjemahkan nilai ekonomi menjadi hasil yang memiliki akibat hukum. Penerapan kerangka tersebut pada transaksi berjaminan, kompensasi, perpajakan, insolvensi, dan eksekusi menunjukkan mengapa konteks hukum yang berbeda dapat memerlukan pendekatan penilaian yang berbeda. Artikel ini menyimpulkan bahwa penilaian yang mempertimbangkan konteks dapat meningkatkan konsistensi, transparansi, dan keadilan dalam penilaian aset secara hukum, sekaligus menyelaraskan hasil penilaian dengan tujuan hukum.]

Keywords

Asset Compensation Enforcement Insolvency Law Market Taxation Valuation

Article Details

Author Biographies

Thao Thi Le, University of Law, Hue University, Hue, Viet Nam;

Thao Thi Le, University of Law, Hue University – Hue, Vietnam
Dr. Le Thi Thao earned her PhD in Economic Law from the Vietnam Academy of Social Sciences in 2015. Her research focuses on commercial and business law, public finance policy, banking credit and payment services law, and auditing law. She is actively involved in the development of academic programs and teaches across all levels of higher education—PhD, Master's, and Bachelor's—in Law and Economic Law. Dr. Thao has supervised numerous postgraduate and Master's theses, particularly in the fields of environmental law, commercial business law, financial law, stock market law, and legal education. She has authored and co-authored several scholarly articles published in international conferences and academic journals related to environmental law, economic and commercial law, banking law, and financial law. Dr. Thao serves as an editor and reviewer for the Hue Journal of Law and Practice (ISSN 2525-2666), published by the University of Law, Hue University, and for the Hue University Journal of Science (ISSN 1859-1388), Vietnam. She is also the Director of the Law Practice & Entrepreneurship Center at the University of Law, Hue University, Vietnam.

Nga Thi Trinh, PT & Partners Law Firm LLC. 270 Huynh Van Luy Street, Phu Loi Ward, Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam

Nga Thi Trinh, PT & Partners Law Firm Co., Ltd. – Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam.
Trinh Thi Nga earned her Master of Laws (LL.M.) in Economic Law from Thu Dau Mot University in 2026 and her Bachelor of Laws (LL.B.) from the Ho Chi Minh City University of Law in 2013. Her research focuses on economic law, with particular emphasis on civil judgment enforcement procedures, land use rights auction mechanisms, and asset valuation. With over 12 years of practical experience working within civil judgment enforcement agencies, she also possesses a strong background in corporate and economic law consulting. She has authored several scholarly articles and pursues practice-oriented research aimed at addressing complex legal challenges in business, commerce, and law enforcement. She currently works at PT & Partners Law Firm Co., Ltd. in Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam.

How to Cite
Beyond Market Value: A Context-Specific Framework for Asset Valuation in Law: Melampaui Nilai Pasar: Kerangka Penilaian Aset Berbasis Konteks dalam Hukum. (2026). SiRad: Pelita Wawasan, 2(3), 355-374. https://doi.org/10.64728/sirad.v2i3.art1

How to Cite

Beyond Market Value: A Context-Specific Framework for Asset Valuation in Law: Melampaui Nilai Pasar: Kerangka Penilaian Aset Berbasis Konteks dalam Hukum. (2026). SiRad: Pelita Wawasan, 2(3), 355-374. https://doi.org/10.64728/sirad.v2i3.art1

References

  1. Barry, J. M., & Sokol, D. D. (2024). Data valuation and law. Southern California Law Review, 96(6), 1545–1570. https://southerncalifornialawreview.com/2024/04/17/data-valuation-and-law/
  2. Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, Office of the Comptroller of the Currency, Office of Thrift Supervision, & National Credit Union Administration. (2010). Interagency appraisal and evaluation guidelines. Federal Register, 75(237), 77450–77473. https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2010-12-10/pdf/2010-30913.pdf
  3. Connelly v. United States, 602 U.S. 257 (2024). https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/23pdf/602us1r31_6537.pdf
  4. Hitchner, J. R. (2024). Standards of value. In J. R. Hitchner (Ed.), Financial valuation: Applications and models (5th ed., pp. 131–162). Wiley. https://doi.org/10.1002/9781119880967.ch2
  5. IFRS Foundation. (2024). IFRS 13 fair value measurement. https://www.ifrs.org/issued-standards/list-of-standards/ifrs-13-fair-value-measurement/
  6. Ilveskoski and Others v. Finland, Application No. 56153/22 (European Court of Human Rights, May 5, 2026). https://hudoc.echr.coe.int/eng?i=001-250511
  7. Immobiliare Bergamella Seconda di Carlo Mariani & C. S.a.s. and Others v. Italy, Application No. 39536/15 (European Court of Human Rights, September 24, 2026). https://hudoc.echr.coe.int/eng?i=001-252396
  8. International Valuation Standards Council. (2025). International valuation standards (IVS).
  9. Korsmo, C., & Myers, M. (2025). Assessing market efficiency in corporate and securities litigation. Indiana Law Journal, 101(1), Article 4. https://www.repository.law.indiana.edu/ilj/vol101/iss1/4
  10. Lederman, L. (2021). Valuation as a challenge for tax administration. Notre Dame Law Review, 96(4), 1495–1516. https://scholarship.law.nd.edu/ndlr/vol96/iss4/7/
  11. Marzal, T. (2024). Conjuring markets: Valuation in comparative international economic law. Journal of International Economic Law, 27(2), 353–370. https://doi.org/10.1093/jiel/jgae021
  12. Ministry of Finance of Viet Nam. (2024a). Circular No. 30/2024/TT-BTC on the issuance of Vietnamese valuation standards regarding professional ethics, scope of valuation work, bases of valuation, and valuation documentation. https://datafiles.chinhphu.vn/cpp/files/vbpq/2024/6/30-btc.pdf
  13. Ministry of Finance of Viet Nam. (2024b). Circular No. 32/2024/TT-BTC on the issuance of Vietnamese valuation standards for the market approach, cost approach, and income approach. https://thuvienphapluat.vn/van-ban/Doanh-nghiep/Circular-32-2024-TT-BTC-the-issuance-of-Vietnam-valuation-standards-for-the-market-approach-628797.aspx
  14. Moll, D. K. (2004). Shareholder oppression and “fair value”: Of discounts, dates, and dastardly deeds in the close corporation. Duke Law Journal, 54(2), 293–383. https://scholarship.law.duke.edu/dlj/vol54/iss2/1/
  15. Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development. (2017). OECD transfer pricing guidelines for multinational enterprises and tax administrations 2017. OECD Publishing. https://doi.org/10.1787/tpg-2017-en
  16. Ripinsky, S., & Williams, K. (2008). Damages in international investment law. British Institute of International and Comparative Law.
  17. Serkin, C. (2005). The meaning of value: Assessing just compensation for regulatory takings. Northwestern University Law Review, 99(2), 677–748. https://scholarship.law.vanderbilt.edu/faculty-publications/425
  18. United Nations Commission on International Trade Law. (2004). UNCITRAL legislative guide on insolvency law: Parts one and two. United Nations.
  19. United Nations Commission on International Trade Law. (2016). UNCITRAL model law on secured transactions. United Nations. https://uncitral.un.org/en/texts/securityinterests/modellaw/secured_transactions
  20. United Nations Commission on International Trade Law. (2017). UNCITRAL model law on secured transactions: Guide to enactment. United Nations. https://uncitral.un.org/en/texts/securityinterests/modellaw/secured_transactions/guide_to_enactment
  21. United Nations Commission on International Trade Law. (2019). UNCITRAL practice guide to the model law on secured transactions. United Nations. https://uncitral.un.org/en/texts/securityinterests
  22. Vaccari, E. (2020). Promoting fairness in English insolvency valuation cases. International Insolvency Review, 29(2), 285–312. https://doi.org/10.1002/iir.1382
  23. Williams, J. F. (2023). Teaching bankruptcy valuations to law students and other unnatural acts. Emory Bankruptcy Developments Journal, 39(1), 51–152. https://scholarlycommons.law.emory.edu/ebdj/vol39/iss1/2/

Similar Articles

You may also start an advanced similarity search for this article.